
On Sunday, Sept. 20, my wife Kari and I went to see Paquin Entertainment’s “The Phil Collins Story” at the Mansfield Theater in Great Falls. It wasn’t on our radar. We went because I’d recently reconnected with my old friend Noah Smith, whom I hadn’t seen in 15 years, back when he was on the production team for “Cats.” Now he works on “The Phil Collins Story,” and when he told me the show was coming west, he offered to get us tickets so we could catch up. We took him up on it.
Before that night, Phil Collins was more punch line than artist to me. I knew him as the “I Can’t Dance” guy who made a cameo in “Hook.” (It wasn’t much different for Noah, who knew him as the “Tarzan” song guy.)
But early on, Noah told me, he felt something magical working with this small crew, breathing life into Phil’s songs. Collins is still alive, but in his mid-70s and with debilitating health problems, he not only can’t dance … he can’t tour. This show is the closest anyone can get to the Phil Collins experience now.

Noah is why we were there. He didn’t make us walk out as fans. Phil did that.
The concert opened with an electric rendition of “Sussudio,” Collins’ 1985 smash that blends R&B, pop and rock, with a Prince influence Collins never denied. It’s a great way to kick off a show, or any party.
Kari — who has never called herself a Phil Collins fan — said the show was immediately nostalgic and fun. She couldn’t resist dancing in her seat. A friend had just told me good music should make you feel like dancing while standing still, and that’s what this show did for us, from beginning to end.
The songs were more familiar than I expected, and the feel-good ones were welcome. But the show covered many sides of the star, including the synth-heavy, almost industrial Genesis sleeper “Mama,” which gets wild and creepy. The laugh alone is unnerving, and Seth Eliser, who plays Collins, delivers it flawlessly.
The talent sets this show apart. Eliser, a multi-instrumentalist from St. Amant, Louisiana, trained in music theater at the Hartt School and has performed off-Broadway. Noah said several performers in the production could take on the Phil role, and that’s no small feat: it means singing his songs in a voice that sounds distinctly like him, matching his tone and impressive range. It also means playing drums on several tracks, including the show-stopping “In the Air Tonight.”

Even the bass player, Peter Michaels Jr., a New York City multi-instrumentalist who has toured with “MJ the Musical,” may be the most talented musician of the bunch, Noah said. The talent blows him away. “These theater guys, I’m tellin’ you,” he said.
Lead guitarist Miles Ahlstrom, a New Hampshire native now based in Brooklyn, got to shine on “I Wish It Would Rain Down,” stepping to center stage to play Eric Clapton’s part. Clapton and Collins were good friends who often inspired one another. Knowing that, I hear some of Clapton’s songs differently, including “Wonderful Tonight,” which I played at a wedding reception shortly after seeing the show. Now I picture Clapton working on that “Wonderful Tonight” riff and lyrics, asking, “What would Phil do?”
The “Phil Collins Story” also gave me a crash course in rock ’n’ roll history. Before he was a pop star, Collins was a prog-rock drummer. He answered a newspaper ad in 1970 to audition for Genesis, a band known for long, ambitious songs, and he played jazz fusion with Brand X on the side. When frontman Peter Gabriel left Genesis in 1975, Collins stepped out from behind the drum kit to sing, and that was his big break. Even the booming drum sound on “In the Air Tonight” grew out of his prog rock background. Collins is not just a hitmaker — he’s an accomplished musician, and a real force.
Whether you’re a Phil Collins fan or not, this show has something for you. It will make you smile, make you move, even make you laugh. (I was flat-out giggling when they did the choreography from the “I Can’t Dance” video.) The show is playful, simple and phenomenal. It’s not a big production — just a great band playing songs you’ll recognize, maybe even identify with. And you’ll leave feeling better than when you arrived.
Don’t take my word for it. “The Phil Collins Story” just wrapped a 36-show run and returns in 2027 with select dates in Canada and the U.S. For more information, visit philcollinsstory.com. And if you can’t make it, please do give Phil Collins another listen.
(As published in the Stillwater County News, Nov. 12, 2026)


Leave a Reply